Come Back Mister Review

cbm_posster
Come Back Mister Review

Nutshell Summary
Come Back Mister is a 2016 sixteen episode Korean drama that tells the story of two men, who unexpectedly die, and are granted a 2 month window to return to earth in new bodies to resolve issues they left behind.

Nutshell Pluses:


1. Likeable Leads. The leads (Oh Yeon Seo and Rain) and the episode 1 “original” leads (Kim Su Ro and Kim In Kwon) cared about their loved ones. Young Soo was overworked and neglected his family in favor of his work. Gi Tak was a former gangster turned chef who could not deny his former love’s request for help. Both leads wanted to help their grief stricken loved ones in their 2 month window on earth. Young Soo wanted to exonerate himself and his family from the stigma of suicide, determine if his wife loved him, and ensure his family could face the future. Gi Tak wanted to raise the status of his former love, an actress, back to an “in” status instead of an “out” status. Whenever a scene utilized both sets of leads in a scene, the emotional ante was increased. The original leads were not cameo roles. I thought the original leads would only be part of episode 1 but they were cleverly woven in throughout the series.


2. Story had comedic flair and dramatic moments. The first segment of episodes had a comedy undertone that both leads delivered with gusto. Rain and Oh Yeon Seo gamely did what was needed to make the physical comedy scenes light and fun. The comedy lessened as the drama moved into the final phase of the series. There were surprises. There were dramatic moments that worked.


Nutshell Minuses:


1. Story meandered and morphed with a final episode plot point that was perplexing. The story started out funny and light, then it meandered a bit (the writer’s path was a mystery), then in the latter episodes the leads’ worlds collided intertwining their destinies in surprising ways. When the writer elected to eradicate one of the leads from existence without a reason I was surprised and confused. I’d watched our 2 leads grapple through 93% of the episodes together, helping each other and then poof, one of them was erased. The rules the given to our leads at the beginning of their 2 month stint on earth: 1. Keep their identify a secret. 2. Not use their body as revenge. 3. Not interfere with the living. Both leads broke these rules, so why one was singled out for eradication, did not make sense. I was perplexed that the coda of the series ended with the host bodies our leads inhabited (who mattered little) not the leads themselves (who mattered a lot).
2. Secondary characters that did not resonate. Young Soo’s wife (Lee Min Jung) was not fleshed out sufficiently to make me care about her. She cried pretty. She had surprising secrets. I never emotionally invested in this character. Gi Tak’s former love, Yi Yeon (Lee Ha Nui), was surrounded by an angry vindictive ex-husband and an evil manager. She was drawn to Gi Tak’s new persona, but she was standoffish and wary (understandable given the past and current men around her). While I appreciated her struggle to reinvent herself, she never grabbed me emotionally.
3. Missed opportunities. Initially the characters stated they could not control what the reactions of their bodies. I thought this could be fun having the leads stuck in bodies that were attracted to or repulsed by others without the ability to squelch actions of their host bodies. That possibility was never explored. Missed opportunity. The epilogues featuring the illegitimate son on the island were cute, then disappeared, then reappeared. When the character was featured in the final episode, I did not care about him, he’d been a sidebar the entire series. The writer missed opportunities to make the character more than a concept so when he was rescued he’d matter. The “who is the father” plot point was raised but never fully resolved. The writer missed the opportunity to strengthen a child’s future. Is it Alzheimer’s or not? One character struggled with memory loss but that plot point was dropped. Bad follow through by the writer. I think you get my drift.

The Characters that worked for me:


1. Gi Tak (Oh Yeon Seo) had a heart of gold for those he loved. Oh Yeon Seo did a terrific job portraying a man stuck in a woman’s body. Having a man’s soul inhabit a woman’s body can be a challenge for the actor. Oh Yeon Seo was up to the challenge. She managed to be manly and struggled to learn how to be feminine. But apart from the physical aspects of the role, Gi Tak turned out to be a man that cared deeply and was willing to sacrifice for those he loved. Unfortunately, the backstory of his relationship with former love Yi Yeon, did not resonate as a great love story. But it did show Gi Tak’s strength…if you need me I’m there. Oh Yeon Seo’s chemistry with the leading man actor, Rain, was superb. Oh Yeon Seo’s chemistry former love Yi Yeon, Lee Ha Nui, was very good. I’d previously watched these two actors excel in their joint scenes in Shine or Go Crazy.


2. Young Soo (Rain) wanted to help his family to grieve and be ready for life without him.  Rain did a good job portraying a mediocre man placed in a sculpted man’s body. When Young Soo explored his new hot body, Rain lovingly stared at his six-pack abs and grinned in glee. I always appreciate Rain’s willingness to portray what a scene requires. Rain can over emote but that’s better than under emoting. His chemistry with Oh Yeon Seo was terrific. They became a unit, helping each other navigate their own goals. As the story line tightened their connections to each other, their close knit relationship became stronger with revelations. How Young Soo died in episode 1, falling from a ledge of the department store to unfurl a banner, yes that sounds ridiculous as I type it, was silly. Everyone assumed he had committed suicide. Young Soo worked to clear his own name and relieve the shame from his family. He was single minded in this pursuit and did not seem to care he caused his wife pain in pursuing this. It was a bit odd that he pursued his newly widowed wife romantically in his new body with vigor.


3. Seung Jae (Lee Tae Hwan) was the silent muscle man.  Strong and quiet men resonate with me. Seung Jae had few lines in this series but his earnest desire to help, even if he chose poorly to make that happen, drew me to him. For a while I thought the writer would pursue Seung Jae’s attraction to the female body Gi Tak was in, but that was dropped. I also thought maybe he’d realize that it was Gi Tak in the body, but that did not happen. I was not a big fan of the writer’s choices for this character in the final episode. He seem marginalized at the end.


4. Guardian (Ra Mi Ran) helped our leads navigate their new reality She was comedic relief most of the them but had a softer compassionate side when warranted. She could have been featured more prominently. She had a crush on Seung Jae too, so I cannot fault her taste in men. In episode 8 Young Soo was scolded for his obvious hints about who he was and was threatened with the consequence of being eradicated from life, so the writer did foreshadow the possibility.

Do I recommend this series? Maybe. This series had good moments of comedy and drama both. I watched this series because of the actors playing the leads. If you like Rain or Oh Yeon Seo, they acquit themselves well in this series. They did what they could. But the story inconsistencies and perplexing plot choices downgraded the overall enjoyment of this series.

OST:

The OST has 23 songs on the 2 disc compilation and 18 tracks were released during the series in a 7 part OST. This is a good OST, plenty of variety with memorable songs. See dramawiki for details. My favorite is song is “Even a single day” by Kim Su Yeon. The playlist is embedded below or check it out via the link.

DISC 1
1. Again by Noel
2. Feel Alive by Topp Dogg
3. Feel Alive (Rap Version) by Topp Dogg
4. Moon Light by Son Ho Young
5. Because It’s Love by Ailee
6. Eyes Shut by Lee Hyun
7. Sadness of Love by Na Yoon Kwon
8. Uncle
9. Spring of life
10. Heaven Train
11. Uncle K

DISC 2
1. Back Then by Ho Joon Topp Dogg
2. X-Out by Ryu Ji Hyun
3. You by Sang Do and Ho Joon of Topp Dogg
4. Two Faces by Su Yeon and Jung Seul Gi
5. Falling in Love by Sang Do of Topp Dogg
6. Even a single day by Kim Su Yeon
7. Department Comic
8. Han’s Life
9. Armageddon
10. Life Style
11. Remembering you
12. Heaven Tension

Recaps/Reviews:
1-2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | Series

Advertisements

Asian drama fan

Tagged with: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Posted in Come Back Mister, Kdrama, Reviews
14 comments on “Come Back Mister Review
  1. Beez says:

    To your assessment of the missed opportunities I can only stamp that with a resounding – Amen! Spot on. Nail square on the head.

    Oh Yi Yeon has created a fan in me and, unfortunately, I tend to not care about most kdrama actresses whereas I’ll follow (and backtrack) the male actors in their future and past roles. The heroines have usually all been pretty interchangeable to me but maybe that’s a cultural thing that’s changing for me. (My very first drama starred Hwang Jung-Eum and I think I stereotyped all Korean actresses as annoying with screechy voices. Either I’m used to it now or I was just plain wrong.) But Oh Yi Yeon is now added to my very short list of Korean actresses whose work I’ll follow. (Kim Sun Ah and Ha Ji Won being the others). Maybe this will start me paying more attention to the actresses. In my defense, the heroines ARE usually cookie cutter characters.

    As I watched Lee Ha Nui in this show, she seemed to come alive and sparkled whenever she shared a scene with Oh Yi Yeon. I wonder how much the directing was involved in that or if it was just the chemistry of Oh Yi Yeon’s full on enthusiasm infecting those around her to join in the zany-ness.

    Rain was excellent, as usual. Can you believe I’ve seen people on other sites saying “Rain cannot emote”?

    For me, I never find him overacting or over emoting. He strikes just the right note for me. (The ahjusshi that he embodied was kind of an emotional boob so…) And while I am a big fan of Rain’s, I am VERY objective with everyone, even my own kids. My eyes are just like that. So I found him over the top only when this script called for it and with just the right amount of grief or pathos and subtlety when the scenes switched gears.

    But I totally agree with your assessment of this series but I’ll admit I’ll be rewatching it again just for the fun of scenes like Oh Yi Yeon and Rain fighting to watch-delete that porn folder. That fight seemed no holds barred and was probably fun for them to shoot.

    As someone who now expects kdramas to fumble at the finish line, I’ll still recommend this show to others with the disclaimer that I give most of the kshows I watch, including my favs – the last episode sucks but the show is worth the ride.

    • kjtamuser says:

      Korean dramas do skew the interesting roles to the men, so I understand your cookie cutter comment. It is fun when a drama offers an interesting role for the women. Shine or Go Crazy certainly had two interesting female roles that Oh Yi Yeon and Lee Ha Nui brought to life. I was pleased to see their chemistry was strong in this series too. Lee Ha Nui is a beautiful woman.

      I’m a Rain fan. Rain has grown so much as an actor over the years. I appreciate his willingness to go for whatever the scene calls for.

      I’d forgotten the grapple over the porn. I loved it when Gi Tak told Young Soo that he NEEDED it. Ha!

      I’m glad I watched this series too.

  2. Jane Tilly says:

    Your call out of the great characters Gi Tak (Oh Yeon Seo), Young Soo (Rain), Seung Jae (Lee Tae Hwan) and Guardian (Ra Mi Ran) were the same characters I felt really made this drama so fun!

    Beez, I think we are in the same boat about generally following actors with a few exceptional actresses. I also added Oh Yi Yeon to my list and had been debating adding Lee Ha Nui too. Thanks to Oh Yi Yeon’s portrayal of Gi Tak, I think this drama had one of the best (and NOT conventional) bromances with Young Soo, played by Rain! ❤

    Gotta ❤ love ❤ the soundtrack! I concur with Beez that your assessment of minuses and missed opportunities was spot on! (h5) I would even completely ignore these negatives, if the writers had just NOT eradicated one of these great characters (U) in the last episode, HUGE mistake!

    This drama was such a fun joyride, that despite the fact that I am furious with the writers and their HUGE mistake—I would still recommend watching this drama. These Kdrama writers MUST quit using soju to resolve their writers block!

    WRITERNIMS: Quit letting the us down with mediocre or terrible last episodes of these dramas we spend our precious time watching!

    • Beez says:

      @JaneTilly – what is (H5)? I’m guessing it’s some type of emoji but I’m not figuring out what it is emoting?

      And I forgot to ask kjtamuser – which of the songs from the soundtrack is the main theme song that played at the beginning and whenever some shenanigans were about to start. The song that says “no,no,no”?

      • Beez says:

        I found the song, but now I’m disappointed https://youtu.be/fvosNAEI8sc
        It doesn’t sound as good as it did on the show. It’s got me wondering if I’ve got some weird problem of only enjoying certain songs because I associate them with what’s going on in the drama at the time they’re playing or if the show producers pick only the outstanding parts of a song to use.

        I had the same problem with a song from Damo and I purchased the Secret Garden sit-up song (can’t think of its name at the moment). But when I play the sit up scene, the notes 4 Men are singing seem so much clearer and sustained a tad bit longer…

        Yeah. I know how it sounds…it’s gotta be me.

      • kjtamuser says:

        Sometimes the sound bite of the song that a drama utilizes is strong and memorable but the entire song doesn’t have the same impact. You aren’t nuts.

      • Beez says:

        @kjtamuser – Thanks for the affirmation that I’m not nuts…not about this anyway. 😆

    • kjtamuser says:

      I hadn’t thought of the unconventional bromance this series offered…but it was unconventional but a total fun, and supportive bromance.

      Concur on the final episode miss. I just don’t understand the WHY. I need a live chat with the writer to understand.

  3. snow says:

    Thanks for the review!
    I started this but then dropped after a few episodes as apart from the comic moments, I found myself not getting involved in other stuff…like the emotional portion of the show and hence, my interest decreased.
    But I have to say….the actors were amazing in this!

    • kjtamuser says:

      I find it interesting the story, the acting, and the production all has to work for a standout drama. When one of these is lacking, you notice.

  4. Jane Tilly says:

    (H5) should have shown up as a High 5 and the (U) should have been a broken heart, but these didn’t work on this site.

    Beez–the whole point of the soundtrack snipets is to make you emote with those moments to make them memorable. When hearing the whole song brings back memories, that is a total WIN. 🙂

    Gotta concur with kjtamuser that “the story, the acting, and the production all has to work”. While there was a piece missing, it was sooo good up until the end, that I don’t regret watching it. However, I am mystified how the writers were able to destroy a great drama with the last episode. I rewrote the ending in my head, so it is no longer destroyed.

    • Beez says:

      Yeah,but the opposite is true for me. I don’t know if they expand the sound somehow on a show, but I am usually disappointed as the entire song seems to not sound as “full” or rich or the note is not sustained…or something. 😦

  5. Jane Tilly says:

    Finally got the soundtrack last week–I am reallllly enjoying listening to it and having it evoke some fun memories from the drama. I have to admit the drama was really excellent until the writers let us down in the last episode. I have decided I would recommend others to watch this drama–there were so many hilarious scenes. I am no longer livid (maybe just irked) at the ending. Maybe that cerebral rewrite was all I needed to come to peace with the ending of this drama. ❤

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Posts
April 2016
M T W T F S S
« Mar   May »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930  
Copyright
© kjtamusings.wordpress.com, 2014-2017, All Rights Reserved. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without expressed and written permission from this site’s author is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to kjtamusings.wordpress.com with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.
%d bloggers like this: