Good Doctor Review

1016871_189110584597493_1384537532_n
Good Doctor Review

Nutshell Summary: Good Doctor is 20 episode 2013 Korean drama about an autistic but brilliant diagnostic pediatric doctor. He is given 6 months to prove himself when he joins a team of pediatric surgeons. Will he be accepted or rejected by his peers, patients, and other medical personnel? Will he achieve his goal of becoming a pediatric surgeon?

Nutshell Pluses:
180px-Park_Jae_Bum_(writer)
1.       Well conceived and evenly plotted story. This series was written by Park Jae Bum, a writer I had not sampled previously.  Jae Bum’s vision was clear for the characters from episode 1 through 20.  The writer provided superb balance to every episode – there was a heart-felt moment, a surprise, and a cliffhanger. I shed plenty of tears watching this series which was laden with touching moments, some sad and some lovely. Jae Bum took a direct and sensitive approach in dealing with the leading man’s autism. Initially, the hospital staff did not want to accept him. But he proved them wrong OR they challenged him and he improved. That is a subtle and powerful. Our leading man wasn’t perfect, he had medical gifts but he also made mistakes and grew. In fact “growth” is what every key character in this series achieved. Before watching this series, I was concerned that two elements would lessen my viewing experience – medical gore and procedural plots. There was medical gore but I learned how the surgeries would go. The subtitles were never placed on top of the gore, so I would watch when a character spoke enabling me to read the dialog and miss the blood. This series was not procedural e.g. “patient of the episode”. Yes, there were several patients but they spanned multiple episodes and each mattered in the sum of the series.


2.       Superb ensemble cast. Good Doctor packed an emotional punch. The writing was crucial and the actors brought this story to life. Throughout the series this pediatric surgical team faced and dealt with the highs and lows. Every actor contributed to this emotional impact of this series. The child actors, the youth actors, the adult actors all worked together to create a hospital staff that I wanted to get to know better each and every episode. The lead characters gelled with the support characters. Characters that initially did not seem to matter, evolved and became important during the run of this series.

Nutshell Minuses
539675_211847518990466_777952080_ndad2
1.       Leading man’s father was an awful man and difficult to watch. This was crucial and necessary to the story. He didn’t learn much from his mistakes. His growth was minuscule. But that limited growth was the correct choice for the writer to make for this character. There wasn’t the cliched “saw the error of my ways” moment for this character. He wasn’t capable of it.

Characters that Worked:


1.       Leading man, Joo Won, gave a flawless performance as the autistic gifted medical doctor, Park Shi On. I enjoyed Joo Won in Tomorrow’s Cantabile (good story for Joo Won’s character) and Young Pal (okay story for Joo Won’s character). But Shi On is the best character and performance I’ve seen Joo Won deliver. His mannerisms for this character never faltered. I liked the character and rooted for his acceptance and evolution. This character touched and helped every character grow. Even characters that loathed him initially succumbed to his honest and kind ways. The romance in this story slow and sweet. Joo Won had excellent chemistry with the lead actress Moon Chae Won.


2.       Leading lady, Moon Chae Won, had a challenging role and hit a home run. She began unsure if Shi On should even be allowed to practice medicine in the hospital. Then she evolved to become his mentor, his friend, his unrequited love interest and finally his mutual love interest. That is quite journey for any actor to deliver and Chae Won did it well. I especially liked when she realized that she felt “more than friendship” for Shi On and how she dealt with this. She didn’t shy away from her own feelings. She handled the opposition to their relationship.


3.       Lead surgeon, Kim Do Han, portrayed by Joo Sang Wook, demanded that his pediatric surgical team deliver the best care for their patients. He wasn’t afraid to doubt, push, and eventually accept Shi On. He openly challenged Shi On to expand beyond his comfort zone and deliver well rounded care not just superb diagnostic skills. Beyond his doctoring skills, Do Han evolved to be more in touch with his own emotions and relationships. He became Shi On’s surrogate brother. The actor, Sang Wook, has a killer smile which the character flashed more as the series went on.


4.       Everyone else. Frankly, every character mattered and contributed. I’m not sure I can say that about any other series I’ve watched.

Moments I Remember:
1150858_198023577039527_1718573483_n
1.       Preemie baby.  I was emotionally hooked to this series with this character.
Good_Doctor-0035
2.       Shi On holding vigil and repairing the red dress. No one understood why he did this but he was undeterred even when directed to stop. In the end, the patient’s parents were deeply touched, and the other characters realized the gift Shi On provided. This was the most touching story of the series for me.
Good_Doctor-0039
3.       Shi On’s drawing on his apartment wall. The drawing represented those he loved and lost. Simply lovely.


4.       Shi On’s setback after his father arrived. When the abuser from his past reentered his life it upset Shi On and affected his ability to practice medicine. With the support of the other characters and his own will, Shi On was able to get back on track but it wasn’t easy.


5.       Brother relationship with Do Han. Initially Shi On viewed Chief Surgeon Do Han as a mentor. But through playing basketball with Do Han, giving a stethoscope to Do Han, etc. Shi On and Do Han forged a brother relationship. The evolution of their relationship was a joy to watch.


6.       Shi On’s song to Chae Won. Chae Won overheard Shi On’s heartfelt declaration through this sweet song. The producer gave us a glimpse of what their future life could be like. How could Chae Won be anything but touched?


7.__Chae Won’s realization that she cared for Shi On as more than a friend. A simple moment of interaction garnered a reaction from Chae Won. She felt a physical response to him. She was surprised and didn’t ignore it. She took her time when she confessed her feelings.
21369B3851FCB59A1C4F93
Would I recommend this series? Definitely. Good Doctor delivered a rich story from start to finish. Throughout the series you experienced touching moments, tense moments, friendship moments, edge of your seat moments, romantic moments, and fun moments. Good Doctor delivered characters and actors with synergy who created a hospital medical team whose cohesive impact outweighed the individual stories of the doctors, nurses, patients, etc. And yes I’m ripping off Aristotle for that statement “The whole is greater than the sum of its parts.”

Special shout out for the recommendation of this series to Mark Freburg . Thanks for the endorsement. I watch and blog episodes of series that catch my fancy. But I also watch other series “for fun” and write a review (almost always). This was a terrific “for fun” series.

OST:


The OST has 19 tracks. The primary songs were released in 6 parts over the series. See Dramawiki for details. Picking a favorite song was difficult. I’ll select “Looks Good” by Ha Dong Kyoon though “I’m Crying” by Baek Ji Young was a close second. The playlist has vocal songs and is embedded below or check it out via the link.

1. Miracle by Lee Young Hyun
2. I Am In Love by 2BiC
3. I’m Crying by Baek Ji Young
4. Looks Good by Ha Dong Kyoon
5. How Come You Don’t Know? by Kim Jong Gook
6. Love Medicine by Joo Won
7. Dacapo by All the Staff
8. Can You See? by Eye to Eye
9. If I Were by Joo Won
10. If I Were (sung by the character Shi On) by Joo Won
11. Green Mes Various Artists
12. Butterfly Various Artists
13. Savant Syndrome Various Artists
14. Shi On’s Dream Various Artists
15. Opening Theme Various Artists
16. Importance Five Stars Various Artists
17. Daily Life Various Artists
18. To My Partner Various Artists
19. From Heaven Various Artists

About

Asian drama fan

Tagged with: , , , , , , , , ,
Posted in Kdrama, Reviews
16 comments on “Good Doctor Review
  1. friday482 says:

    Joo Won was amazing – really talented. I loved, loved, loved this series. Thanks for the excellent report!

  2. Kay says:

    Can’t wait to check this one out! Joo Won is such a talented actor 🙂

  3. mhryu says:

    One drama that I was hooked from ep 1 till end…. beautiful story… and yes each story and character are simply meaningful ☺ my fav… the dog girl…. not only she is beautiful… she acted really well 😍

    • kjtamuser says:

      Dog girl could have been a misstep…a girl raised like a dog…but the young actress and all the interactions were well written and engaging. Touching moment when the singer’s family made her part of their family. So glad this drama was a favorite for you too. This series was superb.

  4. I totally agree with all of your points! For some reason there’s a lot of people who thought that the story was dull and unrealistic but for me it was both exciting and heartwarming. The characters were solid and the script was exceptional. Shiwon’s colorful descriptions and metaphors always rung true with me and there was both humor and gravity in this drama. Thanks for the review!

    • kjtamuser says:

      This was a touching drama, your term “heartwarming” is perfect. Shi On was spot on with his observations. I agree that he articulated things in a straightforward yet interesting way. Thanks sharing your thoughts!

  5. Jane Tilly says:

    I just finished marathoning this series and it was ❤ heartwarming!

    I totally agree with your assessment of the characters. So many excellent characters, in addition to leads that enriched the story. The young girl playing "dog girl" was incredible! Despite some mighty stiff competition, Shi On's dad should win the worst parent in a Kdrama series award.

    One of my friends married a man with Asperger's syndrome, a highly functional form of Autism, after being in a relationship for over 10 years. He is an awesome, but quirky guy, who has become my friend as well. Joo Won's portrayal of an autistic man was AMAZING! While my friend's symptoms are not as pronounced as Shi Won's, I was constantly reminded of my friend observing Shi Won's bluntness, tics and mannerisms! I really liked Joo Won's portrayal of Yong Pal (the writing pales in comparison to Good Doctor) and after seeing this drama it confirms to me what a great actor he is!!! He is so believable in diverse roles.

    I love a good drama with a satisfying ending! I recommend it with a thumbs up!

    • kjtamuser says:

      So glad you loved this drama too. I cannot believe you marathoned the series so quickly! I appreciate your personal insights and opinion that Joo Won’s portrayal was superb. This is his best performance of the 3 series I’ve seen him in.
      AND…the last episode was SOLID!

  6. Jane Tilly says:

    Work was slow last week and as long as I get it done, I can watch on my phone (unlimited data baby)–that, plus the compelling nature of the story enabled me to get through it so quickly.

    I thought the entire series was solid! The only thing not resolved was Shi Won not fulfilling his wish to be able love his prickly, nasty dad–dad stayed nasty and time ran out. The fact that he desired to love his dad despite all the terrible things bad dad had said and done to his family is a testament to Shi Won’s sweet nature. Despite Shi Won’s mom abandoning him, it seems she was trying to atone for her misdeeds by watching over Shi Won and then taking care of that poor excuse of a human being husband until he died. I’m glad he forgave her. I don’t think I would have taken the task of caring for bad dad on once I would have extracted myself from that situation. But then again, I don’t think I would have abandoned my child in the first place.

    • kjtamuser says:

      Shi On had negative reactions both to his mother and father when they came back into his life. And with good reason. Mother abandoned him. It was a bit murky why she abandoned Shi On – loss of her oldest son, escape abusive husband, unable to cope with the reality of Shi On, etc. In comparison abusive Father was dreadful and didn’t regret his actions or apologize even when faced with a terminal disease. I guess Mother was making amends by taking Father away to die but geez I can’t image Father was grateful in any way.

  7. mfreburg says:

    I’ve finally gotten some time to get back here and read your review of Good Doctor. Imagine my surprise at seeing a shout out to me for recommending it to you–wow, thank-you. But I’m more pleased that you liked it as much as I did. And I knew that you would do your usual superb job of reviewing it for everyone else. I continue to stumble around the web and I’ve found no one else writing as well about Asian Drama as you do. (Those folks at Drama Fever included). Thank-you for watching Good Doctor over your doubts and concerns, and thanks for a wonderful review. –Mark

    • kjtamuser says:

      Mark, so glad that you had the opportunity to circle back and read the review. The shout out to you was well deserved, you recommended a terrific series.

      I enjoyed the writing of this series so much I’m considering watching other series from the writer Park Jae Bum. I am leaning toward trying Blood first, we’ll see.

      I appreciate the complements to my writing, thank you!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Posts
April 2016
M T W T F S S
« Mar   May »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930  
Copyright
© kjtamusings.wordpress.com, 2014-2017, All Rights Reserved. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without expressed and written permission from this site’s author is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to kjtamusings.wordpress.com with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.
%d bloggers like this: